When A Monetary Case Has Issur Ramifications - Do We Follow Rav or Shmuel?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words— taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

progress. >> Okay. Discusses raven which began on of if a man assured his son-in-law in Han but he he still wants to give money to his daughter. Yeah, it could happen such a thing that the guy doesn't go for the son-in-law but he still wants to help his daughter. So he told his son-in-law, you know, get lost. I answer you Bahana but you still want to give money to your daughter. So what do you do? You have to like circumn the son-in-law. What do you do? You tell the girl, "Here, I'm giving you this money." Excluding the son-in-law and but I'm only giving it to you that you should buy food and I'm not giving you the food until you swallow it. This way at no point in time the son-in-law gets it. So, Rav takes the Mishna literally that you literally must say on condition the son-in-law has no rights to it and it's going to you when you put it in your mouth. And says even though the Mishna says that he disagrees because he says um the Mishna is going like and says I disagree with that. I hold so you don't have to say I'm only giving it to you when you put it in your mouth. I'm I'm saying I'm giving it to you and it shouldn't go to the son-in-law does not hold Rav holds like holds and so who do we pas and like that's the subject we're going to discuss usually when it comes to monetary matters is like when it comes to the rush says that Rav was uh very excelled in some say was a doctor knew the practicum. The Gamar says

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00progress. >> Okay. Discusses raven which began on of if a man assured his son-in-law in…
2. 0:31son-in-law. What do you do? You tell the girl, "Here, I'm giving you this money." Excluding…
3. 1:31holds and so who do we pas and like that's the subject we're going to discuss…
4. 2:38does he get is does that forbid him from somehow getting this these possessions? In other…
5. 3:43do we say a hand and woman is like her husband we go like when it…
6. 4:51therefore it would only help and you add And so this is a very interesting that…
7. 5:25it's d Ra and the rivet say okay it might be rooted in din but it's…
8. 6:37and no other would help doesn't work and holds No, it's lavka mashi also works but…
9. 7:38>> Just a quick question. Whenever you whenever if I give something over to Freddy and…
10. 8:39know do you need to double stipulate in other words you need to say I'm only…

About Rabbi Daniel Glatstein on Lehallel

10,675 approved videos from 2016 to 2026, 8,906 of them searchable by their own words. Open all of Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s shiurim →

Most played

Tefillah: Journey of a Lifetime - FULL SERIES {B'yomeinu}30:34 · 207K views · Sep 25YOU CAN MAKE IT HAPPEN.....B'yomeinu4:59 · 109K views · Jul 28The Coronation of King Charles III and the Coming of Mashiach {Torah Illuminated Series}4:28 · 65K views · May 8, 2023

More from Rabbi Daniel Glatstein

Avraham Created a Cow #Shorts0:47 · 112 views · Nov 5Raphael the Cow #Shorts0:58 · 21 views · Nov 5The Tunnels to Gan Eden #Shorts0:51 · 124 views · Nov 5The Rambam's Yom Tov #Shorts0:52 · 72 views · Nov 5Mystical Adventures in the Cave of the Patriarchs With Rabbeinu Avraham Azulai on His Yahrtzeit37:41 · 210 views · Nov 510 Sharp Divrei Torah on Parshas Chayei Sarah {Pninei Kedem}14:36 · 783 views · Nov 4

More on this topic, from other speakers

Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 108 by R' Eli StefanskyRabbi Eli Stefansky · 58:45 · 5.5K views · Aug 16Daf Yomi: Makkos 16 | Rabbi Shmuel SilberRabbi Shmuel Silber · 49:37 · 246 views · Apr 24, 2025Daf Yomi: Chullin 50 | Rabbi Shmuel SilberRabbi Shmuel Silber · 53:16 · 206 views · Jun 198 Min Daf - Temurah Daf 7 by R’ Eli StefanskyRabbi Eli Stefansky · 7:14 · 22 views · Jul 26, 2019