Daf Yomi: Bava Basra 39 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

all right say good morning today's is 39 we are picking up 38b are picking up at the two for the bottom remember again we've been discussing extensively the laws of we've been discussing extensively the idea or I should say the discussion about raising objection so now the is gonna ask well what exactly or how is a proper a proper objection phrased says says the foll so say let's say somebody's living on my land and I say Liv I say I say so is say that is not a that is not a proper objection however on the other hand if I say so why not so take a look take a look at the second to last line in the says I'm sorry um no that's the wrong go look look at the previous if I say to Witnesses is a thief that is not a proper objection say what's the issue the issue over here is the following is that in that case where I say Ruben is a thief I have just made made a statement I have not accused Ru I've said ruin is a Thief what does that mean I haven't claimed the land as my own I have not for I have not lodged a formal complaint I'm making a statement that appears to be an attack on ruen but the ownership for myself on the other hand back to the if I say but if I say listen ruin is a thief because he took my land right he's a thief I'm not just calling him a say people call each other ghim all the time right so the idea I'm not just calling him a goov what I'm saying over here is

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01all right say good morning today's is 39 we are picking up 38b are picking up…
2. 3:42that is not a proper objection…
3. 7:30I tell them I need you to be absolutely silent I say now that type of…
4. 11:21land so back to what say why do you need three years why do you need…
5. 15:49is that we assume that when you say something we travels we're Travels by the way…
6. 20:13known to the general populace and once it's known to the general populace again there's no…
7. 25:16to this interpretation everyone will agree with namely once something is known by a group of…
8. 29:02who is witnessing the is the purpose to be if the purpose is then what all…
9. 32:54said so say so just a different distribution but bottom line being the same thing which…
10. 36:45guy Ru is squatting on the land I don't understand once I come along and you're…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.