Masechet Makot Daf Yomi Daf 3

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

31 was just talking about if you remember that we started saying about also and also that we don't pay why do not pay because it is considered sorry they don't pay why don't they pay alas how do you know it's a sob came and he said they didn't do an action and they still got killed and they still have to pay came and he said that it's which means the money is still in the hands of the owners and they still have to pay. So the asks what does that mean the same thing as so the says you're right okay next says and is going to pay according to his what does it mean now he's going to pay according to his if you're going to tell me now each one pays half meaning let's say right now the two of me come and they say that this guy owes $500 so if you're going to come And you're going to tell me that they divided both of them. So then it makes sense. We But we already learned that you divide the money, but you don't divide the lashes. But rather, right? He says, "What do you really think that the guy's going to pay? How do you pay?" He says, "Learned in you never pay unless both of them become." Meaning if only one ed became an he never pays until both become. So says you're right says what are we talking about? He comes into he says listen I testify falsely and since I testify falsely right that's why I have it here. So says can you do such a thing? He says once you said it when you come and you say testimony that's it rather you're right you come into you say listen we testified and we

Jump to a moment

1. 0:0631 was just talking about if you remember that we started saying about also and also…
2. 3:51this second that when they come out of that and they come to us right when…
3. 7:34risks involved. So if you're going to come and you're going to get an old geyser,…
4. 11:28basically obviously how much is the worth which is going to be and everything. Yes. Exactly.…
5. 15:14loan in the freezer so maybe the loan still goes after shmita and three years later…
6. 18:54learned that's what we learned. Okay fine. Remember that whenever there's there's a different okay so…
7. 22:43two different two different versions and each one we don't have a proof but we just…
8. 26:31Ah, no. So then you could do that. You you could say on condition that there's…
9. 30:19planted 30 days before. So when comes that's already one year. So therefore all all you…
10. 34:20So now he comes and he says like this. He says three login right that it…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.