Safed Vs. Jerusalem – The Semicha Controversy Part 2

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Rabbi of of fast it was a great after great deliberation he ultimately chose you shalayim but from the years 1530 to 1580 for that Jubilee period fast try to so to speak uh claim the crown and in fact during those 50 years we could we could make the case that never in history was there a collection of godola Israel from 1530 to 1580 and smash that there was any time anywhere in all of Jewish history and then we learned how the Samsung first said that in 1837 when 90 of the first said that in 1837 when 90 of the population of uh fast perished with a very tragic earthquake and 2 000 Jews died some Cypher roads Pasha Samar that he said it was because of the jealousy of yushalayim so I'm sorry for wrote that it's um it's because everybody they come towards Israel and they go that's fast and they ignore you shalayim you shall I am like a jealous wife took revenge and we learned how the samsiper said that even though everyone's running it's fast though everyone's running it's fast unlocker he says don't count me among them how could you forsake so with that background We Begin one of the most interesting episodes in Jewish history and that is the Smith controversy now just right off the bat we turn to the end and number 21 the Ramos says that you have to know smihab is a formality it's not significant the guy has sneha he doesn't have Smita

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30Rabbi of of fast it was a great after great deliberation he ultimately chose you shalayim…
2. 3:33order to be Makai of malkus which means if someone wore shatness it's alive by Mesa…
3. 7:07to say even though the original smika was hand on head but the subsequent smiggles it…
4. 10:15he's 18 years old there's a tremendous community in Fez 5 000 yeah then he's appointed…
5. 13:22smika how's he going to restore smiko wake up Maestra so he found the Rama and…
6. 16:29Amara he's invoking all of his Torah so the rambam says like this it appears to…
7. 19:48the ram based on almost nothing he says he feels smiko can be reinstituted and then…
8. 22:57that if a guy gets up on a soapbox in Times Square and all the say…
9. 26:15once again we'll have real day on him and we'll have real badinim real Diana's cannot…
10. 29:26rights that we don't exactly know who he gave Smith to we know all the gathered…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.