Avoda Zara 10 (Cycle 13) | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

dismissing him. Dismissing him that he was just giving him a flippant answer in order to kind of just dismiss him. We go and we did according to the Greeks. Then what happens? So sure enough went out did a little bit of research on his own. And what happens? He found the following that outside of in the diaspora we only go ahead and date our documents in accordance with the Greek Empire. Fine. So the truth is our could even make this point. Why why did the Mishna say so we'll say on the first of is the new year for kings and forim and we said what does it mean that it's for kings what's the ramification of having a rash for kings said what it means is for the dating of documents so we go ahead and we go ahead and we start them from the first But then went on and said that on the first of is the new year for years and form cycles and we said ultimately again for years what does that mean that we say obviously we have a question we have a contradiction so say which one is it the first part of the mission seems to indicate that we date based on the reign of kings king the reign of kings begins in the month of Nissan. The way we track it Judeaically is the month of Nissan. And yet then we just got finished saying that what that we date our based on. So which one is it? Do we date our stars based on or based on and we answer and I will say we answer that it depends right ultimately again one is talking about and one is talking about from the say ultimately

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00dismissing him. Dismissing him that he was just giving him a flippant answer in order to…
2. 3:36says it's the day in which the gentile nations coronate their king means they establish the…
3. 7:50you have another race is speaking also about and it talks about his son's his birthday…
4. 11:35I understand what you're telling me. I should ask the Senate to allow my son to…
5. 15:54And he was asking what should I do with her kusto. So sends him back a…
6. 19:41listen to this says Listen, do me a favor. Keep the gold. Because even if you…
7. 23:55servant is dead say we have a concept. We have a concept of say means that…
8. 27:53the only time destroys as if Asov continues to be Asov. If Asov continues to persecute,…
9. 32:16monarchy. In other words, when you wipe out part of your own populace. The Jews are…
10. 35:59the gim is writing the story a little bit shortorthhand but it seems to again meaning…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.