Daf Yomi: Chullin 128 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We are picking up with B 127B and we're picking up at the two dots 2 4 6 8 10 about 11 lines up from the bottom. So remember again the we're talking about the case of an Abraham right or I have I have a limb or I have flesh that ultimately is hanging off the animal still attached by some by some little strand but ultimately again hanging off. So if you remember again so the Mishna said that it's so the case that we're dealing with now over here is if you the so remember again you have the limb that's hanging from the you [snorts] so the Mishna requires the blood of the goes ahead and is the allows the ultimately to be that was ra on the other hand says no that Again the Ibraham Abdul is not it is not readied as a result of the so we'll say now let's analyze says the says the but my plea so we say ask the what is the root of the so we're going to have a number of different versions as to what their is say interestingly enough what are they arguing out. Can the behemoth can the actual body of the animal become a yad? Yad means what? Yad means a handle. So we discussed this. We discussed this I think on Shabas or maybe the end of the end of last week about the tum means essentially something that is attached to another item can become a handle through which to convey tuma from one item to another. So just like the handle of a cle handle of a utensil is attached to the utensil and if something happens to the handle that status is ultimately spread to the rest of the cle so to again by tuma if something is attached

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We are picking up with B 127B and we're picking up at the two dots 2…
2. 3:50what then what the the rest of the animal certainly does not come with that. So…
3. 8:46So we'll say remember again the gimar had to switch around the raim in order to…
4. 12:22they're not connected then of the animal is not the dangling Rabi mayor says no they're…
5. 16:36So says the here we go. So this is actually very interesting. So the of an…
6. 20:57There is no blood. So say one opinion says this is actually very interesting according to…
7. 24:46considered to be and therefore not say it's about five lines off from the bottom that…
8. 29:09say ultimately what happens? I have a stone. I have a stone that is the corner…
9. 32:53so we'll say if you have flesh so say if you have I rip off a…
10. 37:21any part of the animal that is detached from it can go ahead and as long…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.