What To Talk About at the Seder? - The Incredible Machlokes Brisker Rav and Chasam Sofer

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

of the rush monday through wednesday today will be the final share before pesach today we were going to speak about a very important subject and that is we know the torah tells us we have the great mitzvah of sipur you'd see us raym and we have to ask ourselves what exactly should we talk about the night of pesach and i want to present to you today the amazing sheta of the brisker of the griz who has many diyukim to a really wondrous usoid and this you saw it is not unanimously maintained as samsoyfr and others disagree with it we begin with the wise man says what are these laws statutes judgment that hashem our god commanded you to emerily and you should also say to him like the laws of passage we do not have dessert after the pesach we do not eat anything after the carbon pesach so this is a very interesting exchange between the khacham and his father the has a very complex question what are all these laws that god commanded you and you say to him like the laws of pesach tyrion so here it is it's the night of the say there and you're supposed to be telling the sun we were slaves in egypt we were idol worshippers and they embittered our lives and the lord took us out no we don't say any of that we give him we tell him we darshana we tell him the intricate laws of space eat after the compession so that the tampesa should be in your mouth

Jump to a moment

1. 1:05of the rush monday through wednesday today will be the final share before pesach today we…
2. 4:53every night of the year and the sages say no that you do not have to…
3. 9:13mitzrayim the night of the seder but rather the mitzvot speak about it every other night…
4. 14:06so we start to say berka satora and the shiva lake rabbenu it's the beginning of…
5. 18:20that you're always saying the whole night what about the mitzvah of sipper you'd see a…
6. 22:54smithsrayam your mikayim not only by telling the story but also by learning the halachais and…
7. 27:28so the unbelievable so comes rabbi warman and he says and from what pasuk do we…
8. 31:32reason for the mitzvah is we know the whole purpose says of claus israel is the…
9. 35:49only to explain on each thing the depth of the miracle hashem and the strength of…
10. 40:08because if which is according to the rishonim a reference to kabbalah satora as the ebenezer…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.