Daf Yomi: Chullin 69 | Rabbi Aryeh Richter

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

is asking a question on so let's go back just a couple lines it's approximately halfway down the we got this we will do this entire for today and today's as well so what's this talking about yesterday Rob mentioned we have a discussion of an animal that's having a difficulty in childbirth and what happens is one of the come out and then go back in We know clearly that the uber the fetus inside still remains mut again this is of which essentially mut again this is of which essentially means if an animal is if the fetus in the animal's stomach at the time of the works for everything that's inside the animal including the uber therefore if that uber is born whether it's alive or it's or it's not alive it's permissible can be eaten without now the discussion over here is if the animal this uber this fetus stuck in It paused. It took one one of it one of its legs out. One of the legs, one of the paws out and then it goes back in. So whether that then it goes back in. So whether that that let's just call it paw that goes out does that remain under the heter of the and therefore can be eaten or is that disqualified? The leg or paw is disqualified because of the soul of y because it went out of the animal. So yesterday we had the shita of Rav who said no the a that actually came out is disqualified from this benua status and even though the rest of the animal may be eaten with this leg cannot be eaten

Jump to a moment

1. 1:34is asking a question on so let's go back just a couple lines it's approximately halfway…
2. 5:43it is not Why does it have to say? In other words, what's wrong with just…
3. 9:54you can't just eat in your own quarters continue that's how the continues that says the…
4. 14:02going to be permissible. So if you have one limb and three quarters of that limb…
5. 18:08out the spleen. So a person does some type of internal procedure on the animal and…
6. 22:14boundary? The only definable boundary is its mother. What happens? You have a we have a…
7. 26:25responds. If you could combine simmon one and two to permit both the mother and the…
8. 30:32In other words, if the father's going to have a front right paw, the baby will…
9. 34:36in this case you can't there's no there is no way to because there's no is…
10. 38:48meer is not relevant to a fetus or to a limb because it can't walk. He…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.