Masechet Bava Batra Daf Yomi Daf 173

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

says which we learned in just like you cannot come and take out one on the other they canot be on other people as well remember we're talking about two people which have the same name okay so what is the exactly between these two right what's sorry so here the is do we say that sorry so here the is do we say that which is a remember the is considered it's like letters written on a document so do we say that it's going to be acquired with that means giving over the from the Mal to the is enough so right so it's a meaning when you come and you give over a document does that mean now that you make it a form of an acquisition or not our tunel holds yes acquisition or not our tunel holds yes the other tunel holds no okay until here we're clear so says the gim if you want you can answer another answer according to everybody we do hold that means basically is a good form of acquisition but here the question is do you have to bring a proof or not hold you don't have to bring a proof right that in order to collect it even though there's two Yim you don't have to bring another proof why if he has the bring another proof why if he has the document it's probably him ah there's another yimon what do I care but nothing to do with me who has a document he so it's probably him holds no you have to bring a proof that it's this Yim that he's the one that actually lent out the money and not the other one okay stated he says you have to bring a proof or not okay comes and he says how do I know

Jump to a moment

1. 0:08says which we learned in just like you cannot come and take out one on the…
2. 2:13okay comes and he says how do I know what's the proof to my words that…
3. 4:17other and therefore the brother has to bring a proof other people you do not have…
4. 6:55follows imagine if one of them comes and he has a document that says that the…
5. 8:57generations okay we actually learned so basically two two different options either you always go up…
6. 11:32they're coming and saying that's why whenever there's saf you're always going to say it's probably…
7. 13:38the person to a woman the husband's divorcing her right which means that he's going to…
8. 15:42says what's the reasoning why right the Mal cannot be paid back by the the when…
9. 18:20another okay basically like this you're taking the beg of the why because you became an…
10. 20:24to but again it's whether is going to be or not so says one second we…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.