Daf Yomi: Bava Basra 27 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

We are continuing today 27 we are picking up at the two dots 26 B which is 2 4 I'm sorry 2 4 68 10 lines up from the bottom said that if I plant a tree within 16 of my friend's field remember again based on what we saw in the previous stff so the first 16 amas of the root system provide nourishment and the root system provide nourishment and nutrition to the tree so the problem is that if I plant a tree within 16 amas of my friend's field that means my roots are extending into his field and taking up nutrients from his field as a result G who such a person is a thief and we don't bring from such a tree so really a tremendous statement SOI points out over here what's the reason for that because the says you bring first fruits from from your land fruits that grow on your land your land fruits that grow on your land but since technically speaking this tree even though a tree is situated in my land but the roots are deriving nourishment from someone else's field therefore I do not bring incredible says how does know that the tree derives this nourishment from the first six perhaps you say from the following from the following if you have 10 saplings that are dispersed or scattered within an area of a basa called B you can go ahead and literally plow the entire B for the benefit of these saplings up until rash now a little bit of context here take a look at Rashi so Rashi explains actually quite interesting rash okay so let me let me just say this outside the is like this already you're

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00We are continuing today 27 we are picking up at the two dots 26 B which…
2. 3:35another case so I have trees that belong to three different people so all of these…
3. 7:19field and if you do so therefore again that means my root system of my tree…
4. 11:26this Ina's words says only have a little you only have a little bit of land…
5. 15:03is incredible case what if you have a tree and the tree literally straddles the border…
6. 19:13for cloud this in general is also the further metaphor for of is the nutrients of…
7. 22:57to do that now of course my friend is also if he's right he's allowed to…
8. 26:35rainwater what happens if again what happens if an irrigated field you could cut back any…
9. 30:44how much the we'll call it how much are we allowed to cut back that tree…
10. 34:23camel because if you think that is the greater she right right so ultimately again what…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.