Daf Yomi: Bava Metziah 7 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

us begin so today's da is Da z s and we are picking up on so I left you a little bit like in that Cliffhanger over there which is two uh well we call yeah it's two four six seven lines up from the bottom I didn't take myar with me I just I Zer sheet I put my notes on here yeah perfect perfect remember again was trying to figure out this interesting discussion over here when it comes to advanced advanced his interpretation to advanced advanced his interpretation of the case and then the says over here so again remember had said had said that maybe the case was that the person only had a flock of nine and ultimately again this particular suff animal was the 10th animal then subsequently said forget about what I just said forget about what I just said say here here here's what's incredible by the way about like this which is the G could have totally bypassed this entire thing right totally bypassed this entire thing and totally just given us like leave out and totally just given us like leave out ab's first answer especially given the fact remember let say the codifiers of the gimar know it's coming so it's not like the that this unfolded in real time over here so they could have easily eliminated the first answer of ab and just give us the final answer I will say sometimes the gimar teaches us incredible lessons not just from the final conclusion but in the process as well the ability to espouse an opinion and then to say I I was wrong is as great as advancing atically sound and correct opinion as well I say we know this in our own lives how many times

Jump to a moment

1. 1:35us begin so today's da is Da z s and we are picking up on so…
2. 6:15says if you hold that a suff animal does still require is still tithable so then…
3. 10:54to so must talking about a case over here is you had a firstborn donkey a…
4. 15:31something but you have no mechanism of retrieval right no no mechanism of collection then you…
5. 20:12the litigant and therefore technically speaking either party can make it okay fascinating back to our…
6. 25:09look at that significant piece as detached and we say what does this have to do…
7. 29:51the we'll call it the 50% of of Ruan nevertheless that is not how we split…
8. 34:23the loan that the loan took place still there has to be a right the document…
9. 39:03says says if you have a loan document especially like a certified loan document we're not…
10. 43:36now what happens let's say Ru claims I paid it that's my give it back to…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.