Daf Yomi: Bava Metzia 49 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

page a actually we began this yesterday but let's let's back up to over here because this is an incredibly important fure so say you remember again we began to touch of a down payment right you go ahead and you provide a down payment in a transaction so what is the impact and what is the status of that of that down payment what he put down a down payment ra so raav says when you put down a down payment what you do is you acquire a corresponding amount of merchandise so again I'm I'm purchasing $1,000 of wheat I put down $100 I have acquired a corresponding amount of $100 of wheat okay so the says as follows um good um okay says so actually take a look at rash Rashi says over here rash says a little bit further up in the in the short lines in rash says say it's interesting what we're going to have to see in this discussion is that there may be a distinction between a a real property transaction versus a movable property transaction that it could very well be that in a real property transaction everyone agrees that a down payment has the ability to affect the totality of the of the acquisition theal and movable property however could be where R saying that you acquire a corresponding amount of movable property okay that's ra says says no you acquire everything you acquire everything

Jump to a moment

1. 1:19page a actually we began this yesterday but let's let's back up to over here because…
2. 6:26the amount of merchandise corresponding to the am of the down payment so say so once…
3. 11:54and says doesn't acquire acquires see either way bottom line for our purposes you can't acquire…
4. 16:44cancels what do cancel will say that will cancel the part of the debt that's so…
5. 22:11money affects normal acquisition of real property good we're not finished it here we go R…
6. 27:28very interesting sa says you know don't say something knowing in your heart that you're not…
7. 32:21of it and if you do you're subject to the Mish parse so say so what…
8. 37:50gift now here's what's interesting what's the logic what's the logic of that the logic of…
9. 42:37understand how could the Ley start designating this as TR for somewhere else what's the case…
10. 48:11therefore again sure enough was freed from any level of responsibility so they said to but…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.