39 Melachos: Borer (Part II)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

all right good evening good evening let us let us begin so we're Contin um continuing in inor so just I know it feels like uh like a very long time since we've had our last share but if you remember again in our last Shar so we focused on the concept of boder and specifically what we really focusing on is the following idea remember again in order for in the act of B itself is a prohibited shab and again in order to be in violation of again in order to be in violation of borer essentially again one has to go ahead and separate out from o right the the concept of borer itself is I'm taking something prohibited and I'm and I'm separating it from a permitted item that was the classic way that you did borer that's the weat in the chaff so what we've been speaking about is the concept that in order for something to in order for something not to be considered B you essentially have to essentially conform or to satisfy three criteria and I put those on the sheet criteria and I put those on the sheet over here now so number one you have to be taking food from now we haven't actually defined whates is I don't know that we'll get to that tonight that may come a little bit more next week but number one you have to take out it has to be which means that when you have this mixture in order to avoid any Bower situation you have to remove food from the impurity so that's number one number two I'm actually going to go out of order bad you have to do it with your hand and not with a not with a special

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00all right good evening good evening let us let us begin so we're Contin um continuing…
2. 4:14follows as follows says if you go ahead and you do Bor and you separate out…
3. 9:08this that essentially he he's really backing up this same idea that mad is subjective and…
4. 13:53prep is not jux opposed to the meal so if there's a gap ultimately again between…
5. 18:38he says children's clothing children's clothing so this comes up off children's CL children's smaller right…
6. 23:25window girl yes so you could start preparing for your meal before shers by taking out…
7. 27:30some interesting some interesting also discussions in this about like how gravy free does the meat…
8. 32:08Hungarian like a goulash right where you have like a lot of different stuff mixed in…
9. 36:50now on my on my kitchen counter I have a pile of Cutlery is that a…
10. 41:28why should it be fine even for now that's from you're removing the thing you don't…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.