Daf Yomi: Bava Basra 170 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

say today's D is 170 we're picking up on 169 B four lines up from the bottom it's a very interesting case so let's say ruin is claiming that shim sold him land and ruin is proving his claim both through AAR he has a document and Haka he's also used the land for three years uncontested so the which one which one of those two do you utilize in order to of those two do you utilize in order to go ahead and certify his claim so R says R says that we go ahead and we use the over the says no he says that again when faced with a decision between and ultimately again we go with I ask what over here over here interestingly enough is the topic that we've been talking about the last couple of at least yesterday's the last couple of at least yesterday's from the day before as well about namely that when you give over AAR do you give over the totality of the transaction together with that so say now we are on so the says like this top of so again handing over AAR does not really hand over the entirety of of the really hand over the entirety of of the transaction if you look at interesting so therefore so therefore again you don't inquire the totality of the transaction through the and therefore again when when you have both is both is stronger sorry on the other hand holds that no again we've been talking about when you go ahead and you hand over the that gives over the totality of the transaction this statement s just going staple papers over here so this P this statement remember again was uh so so they said this before if that's is arguing on your

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01say today's D is 170 we're picking up on 169 B four lines up from the…
2. 2:38before if that's is arguing on your interpretation before says okay so go ahead and let…
3. 5:26other no it's the witnesses who sign thear that create the effectiveness of thear and therefore…
4. 8:39case lent ,000 and there was a document that said it nowu and shim are both…
5. 11:19thear was written there is no need for certification and therefore again they split the they…
6. 14:21other words so so for example let let me just clarify this a little bit so…
7. 17:00said ultimately means that what even though you didn't need thear but now that you brought…
8. 19:37$1,000 so now obviously shim doesn't want that document in existence anymore because because he doesn't…
9. 22:51interestingly enough procedurally it's the same thing we'll rip up the old star write up a…
10. 25:32aen could go ahead and write write 10 on the same on the same piece of…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.