Masechet Chullin Daf Yomi Daf 9

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Dr. Al Meseca Daf Yomi Daf Tet Amud Alef 91. We're on the second line where it says V'amar Rav Yehuda bar Rav. Says Rav Yehuda in the name of Rav. Talmid chacham tzadik sheyilmod shlosha d'varim. A talmid chacham has to learn three different things. K'tav. Number one, k'tav, to write. Right? You have to know how to sign his name in order to, you know, for documents. So, you have to learn how to write. Number two, sh'chitah. Yeah, and number three, brit milah. In the olden days, by the way, they actually used to do that. Right? When you wanted to smicha, right? If you wanted smicha, it was all the first krach of Yoreh De'ah, Yoreh De'ah Alef. So, Yoreh De'ah Alef included sh'chitah and treifot. Right? In order to do, to get smicha. Afterwards, once they saw that nowadays everything changed, that, you know, you could have just a shochet and then that's it, and he's nothing to do with anything else. So, therefore, they took it out, and that's why nowadays you don't have that. You have the basar b'chalav and onwards. Right? But once upon a time, you had to do all of sh'chitah. And it's true, like I remember my great uncle, right? A love of shalom. I remember he went to, I think it was Argentina at the time. If you wanted a shochet, you go to these places, there's not a lot of, you know, you needed to know, in a sense. So, again, you have shochet, milah, and k'tav. Rav Chananya bar amar, "Af kesher shel tefillin." You also have to know What? Yeah. That's what I said. Yeah. K'tav. Just k'tav. Reading and writing. Basically, the the concept that you're able to read and write. It doesn't mean not a sofer. We're not talking about

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01Dr. Al Meseca Daf Yomi Daf Tet Amud Alef 91. We're on the second line where…
2. 1:34sofer. Yeah? I don't know, because of the b'din, because of all these different things. Right?…
3. 3:37asur le'echol mishechitato." You've got a shochet. That means he knows the practice, but he doesn't…
4. 5:51what's we learned all these things right so therefore what are you coming and telling me…
5. 7:57Someone like Abaye Abaye says, no, that's not the explanation. Hachi Abaye this is what it…
6. 10:04the other he comes and he always in the issue and she would tell you going…
7. 11:35yourself it's still going to be permitted. Why? Because you have a his cut the tail.…
8. 13:37to say maybe there's a there's going to be there's going to be poison there because…
9. 15:44he says you actually even have it when you have a of a doubt whether it's…
10. 17:53is more than so answers also we have just like the is so you can ask…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.