Daf Yomi: Chullin 86 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

He went to Rebei and Rebei told him to take a bird and essentially she the bird over the flax pool. The moths will be repelled or repulsed by the smell of the blood and will leave the flax alone. So if you remember again the gimar said how could Rebi tell him to do that? After all we learned that if you shack an animal and you need the blood you're still how but you would not be able to do under these circumstances. So we have two different versions in the story. So one version said according to he said one version said according to he said you're right said say make the bird a trai and raven said the second version said that rebi said stab the animal right choke it out choke out the animal that way again you know that way it'll die without without and won't be in so we're trying to figure out the nature of these different opinions it says my according to the opinion who says that according to the opinion who says that to go ahead and trafe up the make the animal first before why didn't he just tell to choke the animal or to stab the animal I don't and therefore won't be because maybe you'll say that opinion holds that there is no for a bird and maybe again therefore if there's No for a bird said then maybe the stabbing of the bird is the equivalent of himself said. So that mob was commanded that by you have to the windpipe and the esophagus and a majority of one by a bird and the majority of top you're right which say remember again means you don't have to say this and certainly this

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00He went to Rebei and Rebei told him to take a bird and essentially she the…
2. 3:48so we'll say goes without saying what if you go ahead and as if you say…
3. 7:57may shabas the shabas so ultimately again so what do you see again an entire world…
4. 12:07right in a case say of the mother and the So we'll say same same thing…
5. 15:49say so according to that logic you can say the same thing in the safer case…
6. 20:01say even if you say that the majority of times does do things correctly and only…
7. 24:15which is that you begin to see you begin to see Rabi Mayor's of ultimately going…
8. 28:00reviewed his learning every 30 days. Okay. Okay. So, so bottom line sent word to the…
9. 32:16then cover the blood after that. O as well say is based on the fact that…
10. 36:24say what I would have thought was when I and I do that's a half then…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.