Daf Yomi: Bava Kamma 28 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Master Serge we hope that in the of all and the families in with that let us let us begin so today's D to's is we have a lot to do today really a really incredible a really incredible so ahead of us we are we are beginning we're taking off so say if you remember again if you remember again we left off we left off with the following the following situation has sent the sh specifically regarding the issue of Bas right specifically this idea is an interesting interesting payment we've already discussed the idea you only go ahead and pay Bas if there's intentionality if a person is maed or and now saying depending on how you go ahead and you injure someone one so that determines the amount of the B payment about a very specific case regarding F situation R and shim shared a well each of them had the right to go ahead and draw water from the well on one day on the day that should have been Ru so shim goes ahead and draws from the well what did ruin do ruin hit him with shovel shovel right so then sorry what's the payment ofes in such a scenario like that where ruen strikes shim with a with with a with the shovel so say interesting what respond respond that he could have hit him with a shovel 100 times right he was absolutely entitled to hit him with a shovel in order because again at the end of the day shim was depriving Ruan of his right to the well so that that's that's where we left off with so the says the says uh May so that is 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 from the bottom so again he could have struck him with the

Jump to a moment

1. 1:02Master Serge we hope that in the of all and the families in with that let…
2. 5:51loss is going to continue Ruben doesn't know how to quantify the loss Kim is going…
3. 11:08says rather stand that for yourself stand that for yourself and you could even use a…
4. 16:34loss why is that a case of loss because remember Tam only pay so now R…
5. 21:22you have it out so so the so what does that show you that shows you…
6. 26:55cause the inar no one ask you to stop on the utensil maybe you have the…
7. 32:22yard we say the concern is like this you have a right technically speaking to replace…
8. 37:24side is not pay but interestingly enough the north side is from they will say why…
9. 42:49don't have time for it today the has a much greater this actually it's a fascinating…
10. 48:21slips and dies there won't be liability if shim's utensils get damaged there's no liability but…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.