39 Melachos: Borer-Part IV

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

all right CH say good evening good evening let's begin so I think we have to first finish up a couple of nomos from part three is that correct from from last week's uh from last week's uh Source packet and then what I did for tonight by the way is the packet you have tonight this packet over here the one that's uh the one that went down on the chat that this is the this is the rest of Bor that we're going to do it's not the rest of a of Bor this little more B but the rest that we're going to do we'll see what we get through tonight so we left off in last so we left off in last I believe we left off at source number 11 if I if I remember correctly again might actually might have left off a little bit earlier even at 10 but it's fine we'll get to number 11 soaj here just an important qualification or clarification he writes as follows he says remember again last week we were engaging in the discussion regarding peeling fruits and vegetables remember again you're allowed to go ahead and peel onions and garlic provided that you peel onions and garlic provided that you are using it immediately I isn't that borer isn't that borer so is the answer that's there's no there's no other way to access the item and therefore that's that's normative matter of consumption and therefore it's permitted so if you remember again we took it a step further we took it a step further and we explained about peels where let's say again the person normally eats it right so say an Apple so right so an apple because people normally consume the peel therefore there's really no borderer involved in that in General we spoke about chicken right whether or not

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00all right CH say good evening good evening let's begin so I think we have to…
2. 4:13even though it would seem to be a paradigmatic case of Bora because I'm removing the…
3. 8:51could imagine you have a water with insect so what do you want to do you…
4. 12:55can't drink the wine with the with the fly in there yeah I mean it's not…
5. 17:28originates it's the of the Taz of the Tas so says what's the look what he…
6. 22:21not in close proximity to eating because you're removing some o with it that's I was…
7. 26:32so this is an important s especially again if you are if you're addicted to coffee…
8. 31:21why is this m so the pis writes he says this is not considered to be…
9. 35:28the water over the grapes skins but again in the grapes skins you have to have…
10. 40:12coffee yeah I as long as you're not taking it out I I don't I don't…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.