Amud Yomi: Megillah 17b | Chaim Spero

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we are picking up on y we on the last line of the Y um okay so tonight's Kamar we're actually going doing a lot ofum that relate to to Shon EST so I got to sit her out when we get to it but okay here we go so the the right now the gamar is trying to figure out the gar is saying that um that uh that you cannot skip when it came to Hal you can't do it when it comes to uh Kish can't do when it comes to so so we already established about how we have so now thear says kma about how we have so now thear says kma how do we know that for kishma that you have to you have to say it in order without skipping it so is going to go off a little bit of a tangent and then it's going to come back and it's going to show how you have to read it without going out of order that when someone's saying kma you have to say it in the way that that it's written you have to say it in Hebrew you can't say it in any other language argu they say you can say it in any language that you understand it so my time of the rebi what's the reason that rebi says you can say it in any language that that they have to do it in only in Hebrew turning

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we are picking up on y we on the last line of the Y um okay…
2. 1:31so says ask reab Nami HMA how does Reb understand why doesn't he why does he…
3. 3:34any language why because if you say that the whole Torah can only be said in…
4. 5:35go through every P all the Bros why the why the Bros are put in the…
5. 7:37go how do we know that you're supposed to say the verse is supposed to be…
6. 9:41says why do we have the after should be the why do we go to answer…
7. 11:14talking about in that P is talking about theu of the not the of a physical…
8. 13:16so because the the is given on the eth day so therefore they they uh correspondingly…
9. 15:19all the the stuff on the mountains when you're driving in stone and you see everything…
10. 17:24of the so I'm G to lift up the and you're going to have the are…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.