Daf Yomi: Rosh Hashana 19

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

you remember again yesterday we left off by dissecting the PK in zakar where the nvi goes ahead and discusses a number of different fast days the so we're continuing to go through that list so the says what is the seventh fast day now second wide Line This refers to the third of what we call what happened on the third of G was assassinated who killed G A Man by the name of is another Jew just understand this is right after the destruction of the first bikash so G was a governor who was installed byar representing some level of Jewish autonomy with the assassination of G the Jewish situation becomes much more compromised so therefore again they instituted a fast day the third of TI and it teaches us an important lesson say what's interesting about this as as we're going to see we've already seen that ultimately again there's a fast of Tish right destruction of and the fast of the assassination of aad to which the tells us that we see from here that the loss ofik is as traumatic as the loss of theik a very profound statement say why are we calling the seventh fast day the seventh fast day say once again what we begin to see is in this the way we're tracking time is how from KES Nissan fromes Nissan so TI is the seventh month fromes Nissan what's the 10th fast this refers to the 10th of so here here we have you know an explicit which indicates to us that is besieged on the 10th of on the 10th of so once again why are you calling the 10th month once again we see this theme that these months are being reckoned according to

Jump to a moment

1. 1:06you remember again yesterday we left off by dissecting the PK in zakar where the nvi…
2. 7:15agree that there is there is a but interestingly enough he holds that that is not…
3. 13:13minor where say I just want to point out the only manifestation of the of identity…
4. 19:06example so say what they would say is it's by the way it's interesting over here…
5. 25:09so if it's already a y why do you have to make it into another y…
6. 31:10from the creation of boundaries if I live life on the line between M and and…
7. 37:03what did and his friends do listen to this they went and they went to a…
8. 42:54mayor and rabie mayor's T was was yehud sh so already you're a couple of generations…
9. 48:46persuasive they spoke to the Mata the Mata spoke to someone whatever whatever there's a whole…
10. 54:41is right everybody pass Universal judgment yet Kaz made the call that it is better for…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.