Q&A - Understanding Stories, Evil Eye, and Ordering Jewish Law

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Q&A so the floor is open can I start yeah sure so in the previous lecture a rabbi came here and he gave us a question he gave us AAR and he said there were two said they came and they got married for 10 years and they couldn't have kids so they went out and they married other partners right and it was they Ed this gamar as an as they Ed this gamar okay soed they got married for 10 years to to to t the game on the same level and then the wife got married to a man on a spiritual level lower than hers and then he she was she managed to lift his spiritual level up and the man got married to a woman with a spiritual level lower than his and she pulled him down so I was wondering if every gamar like is that just like is that just aess specific like one time thing or every gamar does that represent like the average well you just presented two extremes and often the truth is somewhere in between uh the wouldn't tell you something that was only true about one case because then what would you learn from it uh you know history has in it an Infinity of facts so whenever thing something is presented from history there has to be a reason why this was chosen and all the rest were rejected usually it's because you can learn something from it um are there exceptions yeah usually there are exceptions to rules find absolutely Universal rules is extremely extremely difficult um do black holes

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Q&A so the floor is open can I start yeah sure so in the previous lecture…
2. 5:50you would say he won the lottery what a waste what a miscarriage of Justice ah…
3. 12:16strict and the penalty for violating a misdemeanor is much less strict but it's the same…
4. 18:04think so the problem was you don't know what to do you go to the highest…
5. 24:32players well you might have some discussion there mightbe let's say 20 some of who say…
6. 30:56call this keeping you philosophical balance this this is goes back to GE Moore Cambridge in…
7. 36:40music there was actually music that came down as part of the way in which a…
8. 42:54pain and the anguish of suffering itself and the positive benefits so for example something good…
9. 48:43life I guess not because he created in such a way that you change and grow…
10. 55:09omnipotence and Evil part one where I go through this in great detail you can you…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.