Daf Yomi: Bava Metzia 38 (Shabbos)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

all right say good morning let's uh let's begin today's 38 we are picking up on 37b at the two dots so 2 four six seven lines up from the bottom beautiful beautiful dot today thank you Al remember again the mishna the mishna gave the case of where ruen and shim both deposit utensils with the Sher one was worth 100 one was worth 200 of course they both come to claim the utensil and both claim the 200 zo utensil so what do we do we give the smaller utensil which was worth 100 Z to one of them and we go ahead and take 100 zus from the large utensil so whether that means we break off a piece of larg utensil we sell off the larger utensil whatever it is we pull out $100 from the larger utensil give that to the other party and of course again the rest of the amount goes ahead and remains until comes says says ultimately again why do we need both of these cases remember essentially the repeats the same case twice just the first time it does it with money and the second time it does it with utensils so why do I need both cases so remember again one more piece in the Mish RAB is always of the opinion that in any of these cases where you have contested ownership he says put the whole thing in escro the whole thing in escro why what's the logic cuz says otherwise what is to stop a person from lying what is to stop a person from lying if at the end of the day they know what's worst case scenario they're just going to get their $100 back therefore again order to go ahead and in order to go ahead and make sure that people don't lie so again the entire amount goes

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00all right say good morning let's uh let's begin today's 38 we are picking up on…
2. 4:21what we usually do in this situation is we'll go ahead and we'll give out 100…
3. 9:13because then I understand the meaning of this price therefore once the Sher can't touch it…
4. 14:16that was like shouldn't I be concerned then maybe there was excessive spoilage of the produce…
5. 18:35have happened prior to the excess of spoilage the way we go ahead and deal with…
6. 23:21show up the problem is you've got a soup kitchen filled with food you want to…
7. 27:59spoiled to the point of no return it doesn't matter if it sits anymore not you…
8. 32:16comparative to step in sell off the produce under the opes of Basin in order to…
9. 37:01say is it not because it's one reason in both cases to which the says in…
10. 41:45says ask why is the repetitive after all going to kill you I'm going to kill…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.