Daf Yomi: Succah 51

What’s said in this track

The opening of this track, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

you I have my hands full with one phone all right that let us begin so days we're picking up M middle of the page remember again literally middle of but it's okay it's a short short short on 51 supposed so remember again just to reorient ourselves a little bit so we had an interesting we had a the was talking about whether or not the playing of the the playing of the flute was or not not the playing of the flute was or not not held that the playing of the flute is said the playing of the flute is not only not it's not even wanted to say that the fundamental between the two of them was concerning what we know that there is a Mitzvah of in theik right there's ltic song in the bikash the ultimately is is as follows do we say or is the primary sh ultimately again just is the primary sh ultimately again just verbally or is the ultimately with with um with instruments SOI wants posits that's that's and says that the flute is he holds the who say that the flute is not playing of the is not ultimately again he not ultimately again he holds says how do I know that this is their actual we learn what happens if you made a a service utensil out of wood out of wood so re says it's P and R says that says says says what are they arguing about remember the is in question is an instrument can you make an instrument out of wood or not the one who says ultimately again that is ker he'll hold that says they W say this is fascinating Rashi points this out over here if you take a look rash for just a moment Rashi says almost like right across in rash is the opinion who holds that you

Jump to a moment

1. 1:01you I have my hands full with one phone all right that let us begin so…
2. 5:17an indispensable part of the and therefore again that makes an instrument by the way a…
3. 9:59thing which is Earth and wear so you can't although you can make a clich out…
4. 14:09the you know what they're arguing about they're arguing about the what happened what happened in…
5. 18:55just there to amplify theim of the drawing of the water so the the flute really…
6. 23:39he will say that and ordered the playing of the instruments why to beautify the Shir…
7. 27:52this on the first day right on the the second night of right say simply right…
8. 32:30are playing all kinds of instruments are playing instruments more instruments that you than you could…
9. 36:38beautiful so beautiful we're going to discuss this more but the says whoever did not see…
10. 41:18says so Herod said to the said to the remaining rabbis I'd like to cover the…

Every second of this track plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.