The Chakira of the Chacham Tzvi to Explain the Machlokes Rashi and Tosfos About Chalitza Pesula

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

regarding what exactly is halitza pasula so Rashi says that we're talking about a case that RAV mentioned where you had three sisters that fall to Two Brothers where we say the first brother yeah Yehuda does Khalid and yes and the third sister that falls Bella gets khalitza from both and the gemara says the fact that they each do halitza to one indicates zika the the fact that they both do khalisa to the third one excuse me indicates and the fact that they both need to do halitza also indicates that khalitza Sula you need to do halitza from both look at Rashi Rashid Khalid says from the fact that it says you need halitza from both that means he holds Alima Mitzvah zika sivamen the Mitzvah of the zika of ibom to throw him on both is for sure doesn't mean it's disqualified it means it's inferior why shimratzalia the reason why khalidza is a halitza gurua because since if you wanted to do ibom why can't they do even to billah because billah is both Levy and uh both yehudanyasacharsasi here therefore it's not and therefore she needs to go and get khalitza from everyone because the zika of both will not be removed with only once it's placed on both of them that if you would say anzika then the zika would not be placed on both of them it would only be on the bias this is what uh this is what Rashi seems to be saying in other words us yesterday we discussed in shul why what the writer is yes apparently what Rashi is saying is

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30regarding what exactly is halitza pasula so Rashi says that we're talking about a case that…
2. 3:48that you can't do even but I could do khalitza doesn't khalitsu remove zika why is…
3. 7:02weak the khalidza's ability to remove the zika is also equally weakened okay so I want…
4. 10:22supplanting the brother I am in lieu of the brother so when I could do e…
5. 14:11so the ramban seems to be going with firashi's shot that the definition of Khalid is…
6. 17:54you want to sound like you're a Bucky say over this hakira nobody will know it's…
7. 21:08nirolanias deities even if that was not his mindset at the time he did the Khalid…
8. 24:57Kenyan so don't do the Kenyan but if it's a Mitzvah we would force him to…
9. 28:38we say you're now to do even why oh you're saying um also about the musliman…
10. 32:19of exempting you from that responsibility comes to remove from upon you the responsibility of ibom…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.