If a messanger gets a free item who does it belong to

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we're going to share with you a beautiful shoe this morning that has to do with a very interesting topic sometimes you send somebody to buy something in the store and it's a buy one get one yeah so i send my good friend he buys it buy one give one three who keeps the free one the shalia right the messenger or the balabaite the one that sent it that's the question and all these cases it could be a repeat site it could be you know i just some gave you the bible you know i just some gave you the bible and get one but there's many cases like this so let's just see what the shoe today is going to speak about it's a secret so if it's something that has a set fixed amount they gave you an extra amount you bought one you get one free buy two get two free or if you get three it's a price of free or if you get three it's a price of ten three for ten dollars right for example you come you sent me to sell ten tell me rabbi get me three doritos yeah i come and i say one second i could get four for the price of three so why am i going to get three i give you the three you pay for your three i'm gonna take the free one and that's it so therefore what happens is and he gained from it he went and he gained from something if it's got something which got kicked out which means they have to fix the amount

Jump to a moment

1. 0:04we're going to share with you a beautiful shoe this morning that has to do with…
2. 3:12here here's the cake say i'm gonna give it to my mother no that's for you…
3. 7:05let's say ten thousand dollars she sold it right she sold it for the opposite whether…
4. 10:17he says one second without the money of the of the without the money of the…
5. 14:17why is the rama bringing this down so now technically speaking the madame did not even…
6. 17:51whatever the case was you bought it for 120 who gets a change who keeps the…
7. 21:40to get money as a payment from right so now here is why over here does…
8. 24:59he comes and he buys a and he receives a stender as a present who gets…
9. 28:37he also bought it for himself so when he paid together he doesn't have money of…
10. 31:41each one gets gives him one one one one and he comes and he says you…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.