Daf Yomi: Bava Basra 169 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

today's is we are picking up on 168b and we are picking up six lines up from the bottom so the says as follows says so a very interesting case over here so let's say again Ru shows up in B and Ru says I lost my loan documents Ru said that he L he L shim $1,000 and he lost the loan document so the rashan points out to something very interesting rash rash says and ultimately again sorry let just shut this off and again andash says over here they so what is ruin asking for ruin saying B I'm asking you to go ahead and write for me a brand Newar and I'm asking for you to go ahead and write everything that was included in the firstar the case over here is he doesn't have witnesses Ru doesn't have witnesses have witnesses Ru doesn't have witnesses that he lost the star so he's coming to basen saying I lost the star but he doesn't have witnesses that say that he lost the okay so what so it's interesting because to indicate contrary to the rash says even though Witnesses come along and say yes we wrote it and we signed on it and we delivered the we do not write another says when is this says when is this so this makes a lot of sense this is true when with a loan document why what's the issue with a loan document the is should loan document is if Ruan ends up having two loan documents that sets up the possibility for what double collection double collection however says ever again when it comes to documents of sale for that we could go ahead and write so this is interesting if ruen went ahead and sold something to shim

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30today's is we are picking up on 168b and we are picking up six lines up…
2. 5:08document holds you also can't write a second sale document what are we concerned about we're…
3. 9:46go to other people that Ru sold to and I'm going to seize their land say…
4. 14:26not right and any which does not have written in it that so what do you…
5. 19:43just gone through this entire piece over here but the is looping back not to the…
6. 24:19would get it at a discount CU because you're assuming risk here just to be clear…
7. 28:56included okay Rashi says no Rashi on the other hand say he disagrees he says for…
8. 34:04already sold without a guarantee so essentially is saying that she's going to get the guarantee…
9. 38:52hereas says says that essentially it's like that that that that I that I say to…
10. 43:25consideration you have to what what what am I getting what am I getting for this…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.