Sefer Yona: Chapter 4 - The Malbim Explicates Why Yona Wanted To Die

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

basically uh commanded to tell the people to do chuva and that was one of the reasons why Jana didn't want to go because he didn't want them to do chuma we'll crawl out some of funai and the second time um Yana is just told Kum Lake napakas so the Apostle Kevin said that Jonah did so the Apostle Kevin said that Jonah did what which means he took it very literally Yonder was actually masupuk if he should tell them about the first umua and rebuke them or he said well look this time God didn't tell me to rebuke him he just told me to tell them they're going to be destroyed in 40 days and therefore Jonah did not actually tell them to do chuva however the people of ninvee sort of figured out on their own that if God is letting them know that they're going to be destroyed know that they're going to be destroyed then obviously he wants them he's giving them the opportunity to do chuva because God doesn't just release information as a press conference FYI if the advantage time is sending a navi to tell them to do is sending a navi to tell them that they're going to be destroyed obviously it's in order to give them the opportunity to do chuva which they do and they know to believe young and here's a guy comes in he started yelling at them and they believe him and they change their whole way of life how do they know so okay that's a good question

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31basically uh commanded to tell the people to do chuva and that was one of the…
2. 4:06you're kind of the beam and it's enough to pay with it but it's nevertheless um…
3. 7:40our fasting so if he's not just not fasting so what do we do it for…
4. 11:20it was supposed to occur to them naturally based on the constellations then they would still…
5. 15:33and regardless nevertheless God relented heaven understood why is Hashem allowing them to survive it's not…
6. 19:10what five times rights those who are musakians were soymek at the end of the United…
7. 22:54though he was concerned Hashem has the interest of Venezuela at heart it still leaves he's…
8. 27:01has to die I mean that's got to be the quintessential rhetorical question Yonder just says…
9. 30:43so my mom asks in his beer in his Shea lice why did he sit east…
10. 34:24Connor has difficulties is uh keeps out all of a sudden it must have been super…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.