Vayechi: A Rebuttal on Behalf of the Chashmonaim, The Ran & Abarbanel's Disagreement with the Ramban

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

and the law sticks from between his feet until Sheila comes and to him will be the Assembly of people okay so this is a rather mysterious fasok that the staff will never be removed from Yehuda what staff is this referring to what law giving stick is this referring to and the gemara says the Sanhedrin and that's hey number three because the time you learned in the rest of the lawyers says like more it's not referring to Kings Kings now referring to rulers uh in the traditional sense but rather ELO Russia goliathusis refers to the race galusa the leaders of the extra large the leaders of Babylon as Israel that they dominate they rule over Jewish people but shave it with a staff refers to the political leaders of the Jewish people what does it mean and a law Giver these are the the descendants of Hillel these are the the descendants of Hillel that teach Torah publicly so according to the gemara this refers but rather refers to the rulers of the Rich galusa and to the teachers of Taira the descendants of hello okay that's what the gomara says there is a very famous ramban that I would like to look at very carefully are very beautiful words in the tire I'm sorry you don't know what they mean yeah sorry you don't know what they mean yeah I'm not telling you today that's not what the show is about the show is about lawyers maybe next year we'll get up to akiava hey actually who is she like but that is not the topic of today's show well we like to look at as the the ramban what ramban understands to the loyal Sushi mihuda and what I would like to do today is offer a rebuttal

Jump to a moment

1. 0:33and the law sticks from between his feet until Sheila comes and to him will be…
2. 6:16and he inherited to Yehuda the Dominion of now I just want to point out if…
3. 12:35Hashem they're not just rejecting you they're rejecting me as well you should have a king…
4. 18:58yaakov um and they were usurping inheritance yaakov gave the Arusha of maluka to Yehuda so…
5. 25:38had their slave Rebel and take maluka from them it was Damascus transferred by lineage was…
6. 31:48true anyone who violated it got punished yeah they got punished that just means that's the…
7. 38:03it was the Greeks and then it was the Romans it was the Romans well we…
8. 44:25okay I'm not giving you everything you want all eight you're gonna have to go to…
9. 51:20not a guy but anyway that barber now ask look at number 22. the fourth question…
10. 57:47leadership will always come from Yehuda and I'm gonna read to you now from the ability…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.