Daf Yomi: Bava Basra 117 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

follows the daughters of went ahead and inherited essentially three different portions now we'll have to see exactly what this means that they actually inherit three different portions overlapping portions we'll discuss this in the gim what were the three portions they inherited number one their father their father had a portion because he was one of the Jews who left Egypt that's portion number one furthermore against obvious he had a father right his father was his father was right so ultimately again he had so they had a portion had a portion in his father's property so obviously as we've established when someone inherits when someone inherits even when they pass away their heirs inherit their heirs inherit their inheritance position so therefore they had a portion in's possession and number three Lastly lastly was a was a he was a so because was because was a firstborn ultimately again he had had a double portion so those are the three portions right so I have to see exactly what that means 1177a so says something very interesting we say we going to see something very interesting a fundamental fundamental dispute how was is divided up or amongst whom was it divided up so the says our mission reflects the opinion that was divided up amongst the Jews who left Egypt let's analyze this a little bit First Take a Look take a look at for just a moment you know let's read first says was divided up amongst the Jews who left Egypt because the says literally again in accordance with the names in other words the whole the land will be divided up by a

Jump to a moment

1. 2:14follows the daughters of went ahead and inherited essentially three different portions now we'll have to…
2. 5:22into the land so how do you reconcile those two different things right on one hand…
3. 8:45right because it's easier for us to imagine a division of land amongst living people right…
4. 11:59so we'll call it elazar has one son andar has two sons has two sons and…
5. 15:42way right that when you had AER andar remember what Happ withar andar decided we're going…
6. 18:52says to these who's the these who's the these the Jews entering the entire so says…
7. 22:02get their own portion in Isel so therefore again whose portion do ru's kids get his…
8. 25:45both you get two portions you get two portions listen to this we say what happened…
9. 29:00so say this is fascinating so apparently again the complainers which again we'll have to see…
10. 32:18have two minutes sun's coming up it's beautiful it's also a longer tomorrow the shorter that…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.