Daf Yomi: Chullin 75 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

the families all those who need together continue to look after our brothers and sisters in allow our holy soldiers to be success with that. Let us have a lot to do today. Today's 75 we are picking up on B. We left off and we got a little bit further. Let's just back up to the lu which is on 74b four lines up from before the lines get wide. We actually read this question in wide. We actually read this question in yesterday's do but let's uh let's just jump right back into it. So are you able to go ahead and redeem a firstborn animal with a benqua? So let's remember again is if there's a firstborn donkey that that goes ahead and has kadushna. Interestingly enough, you might wonder to yourself, why is it that a donkey, which of course is a which is a non-coosher animal, has sanctity, has firstborn sanctity. In fact, it is the only it is the only example of this. Again, we know that generally firstborn Again, we know that generally firstborn kosher animals do have a sanctity. But we do not find any concept of a non-coosher firstborn animal having sanctity. The only example of that is the donkey. What's the what's the explained very beautifully? Because the donkey was the beast of burden which aided us when we left Egypt. So again because the donkey carried our possessions because the donkey carried our stuff the riches with which we left Egypt. Therefore again there's a special almost I don't know what the right word is now. wouldn't call it affinity or connection but almost like hakara

Jump to a moment

1. 1:19the families all those who need together continue to look after our brothers and sisters in…
2. 6:00So on one hand we can say listen since this animal has become totally permitted with…
3. 11:10mayor No, it's still called the ben and it is totally permitted with the of its…
4. 15:44the same way that permits something for consumption also goes ahead and makes something The act…
5. 20:54and then if it goes into a cemetery, now it's it becomes soa end of the…
6. 26:05confusing in the eyes of the gimar right imagine how confusing we are right imagine how…
7. 30:42says ultimately from the moment they can no longer live then it's by the way what's…
8. 35:58prohibited status age maturation since this was a fully formed 9mon fetus therefore it's says no…
9. 40:45the mother was a traa you find inside of the mother a living fully formed fetus.…
10. 45:58possibility of incredible. So the say and who according to whose opinion does the ben require…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.