The Book of Ezra: Chapter 10 - Grand Finale and Siyum

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

foreign they gave them advice to get rid of their wives and bring a guilt offering for their guilt now what kind of guilt offering do they have to bring for living with God there's no ordained carbon for marrying a guy it's alive in the Torah but there's no prescribed carbon that has to be brought Surah says this was a one time special a special occasion and even though normally don't have the right to say just bring a carbon why because if you just bring a car and you bring a Hulen into the Azar you're actually being uh you're being you're violating the the kadusha of the mikdish we're coming we come back what I should bring in the dog awesome right so this case Rashi says this one is a special harassa comes the album and the album says yes exactly three it doesn't have to be no the best the uh determined this was appropriate for this situation to bring special carbon however malvin points out based on the command Crystal Staffing aleph that in fact this did call for a carbon auction why because there's something called ashram harufa right which means like this that if a person has relations with the shifra cananes who is engaged to marry inevitary if you live with her then you have to bring in ashram so says in fact this is what happened the Jews in those days they lived with who we know that a normal a Jewish man is now to live with the Canadas but an evidently he's allowed to live with a ship so if that is engaged to marry nevitivity if you live with her and you violate so to speak her formal relationship that she's engaged to marry the evidence every you have to bring an awesome so the question is why would Rashi have

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30foreign they gave them advice to get rid of their wives and bring a guilt offering…
2. 3:44if you continuously living with them you gotta chase them out you want to know could…
3. 7:12strong you need Roy um and since and Rashi holds the dinner of every is only…
4. 10:23guard who's not a sheikho but engaged to another guy does it make a difference no…
5. 13:44the singers you know these guys had good CDs they put out good in the Jewish…
6. 17:08the concept that sometimes you need to uh act in a uh external arrogant way to…
7. 20:43that they wanted to do the right thing they wanted to listen to Ezra and therefore…
8. 23:52Ezra so then even though originally originally what it was what was it supposed to be…
9. 27:12they say [Applause] start we don't know no information is given except for the 20th year…
10. 30:23and and then they didn't stop but then who built it who was involved in building…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.