Daf Yomi: Bava Kama 57 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

for the safe return of all of the hostages and their families to their families and we dedicate our Shear this morning Captain Harel who was killed in battle yesterday we hope that in the Merit of his will have and of course we dedicate all master sergeant providing for his family say with that let us begin we have a lot to do today a really a really exceptional da so we are picking up today's D is 57 we are picking up on 5056 B at the first wide line thank you remember again we're dealing with the following we're dealing with the of here's what the mishna said the Mish the Mish gave us the statement Mish gave the statement that that after you give the animal to the shepherd so the shepherd assumes responsibility for the animal so we're trying to figure out what exactly that means say if it means that when the owner gives the animal to the shepherd so the shepherd ultimately assumes responsibility we've kind of seen that already and it seems to be somewhat obvious and intuitive so instead interpreted to mean they must be talking about a case of where the owner gave it to a Sher to a custodian the custodian transferred it to a second custodian and is teaching me that that second custodian assumes full responsibility all the says is that's very interesting because this seems to refute the position of RA because ra is on record as saying that sh if one agent gives it over to a second agent the first agent retains complete responsibility to which the awar says you're right maybe we're talking about a different case of a person who gives over his sheep to a shepherd and the shepherd gives it over

Jump to a moment

1. 0:35for the safe return of all of the hostages and their families to their families and…
2. 5:26what's at the end of the day at the end of the day so responsibility remains…
3. 10:45Exempted from something else so for example points out theage we're actually we're doing this he…
4. 16:08visibility say what's definition of high visibility that ultimately again the person the owner goes in…
5. 21:06to listen to this say this Outside Inside actually look at say if you find a…
6. 26:26to not necessar maybe what it means when it says that you could return it to…
7. 31:50stolen it turns out that he stole he stole it he has to pay soash says…
8. 36:47obligated to pay Ken just principal because L is like a g or is he to…
9. 42:23principle it's only in a case in Theft where we were totally exempt himself like where…
10. 47:59not a case of ly this is I'm telling the truth right so I I I…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.