question and answer

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yonah Carlebach’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

three things that happened that effectively yeah three things that happened in recent i say memory that which affected all of us in kalyatra and i'm going to mention um if anybody has a problem with electrical films worry hamilton there's no problem um it's a new fan yeah that's it it's a new fan that they banned yeah it's a little bad that it looks more realistic i heard one rob say that he said he said all that from me to all those things i had nothing to do with women right okay so basically the three things that have happened to us all as members of of clay israel is uh sam iran let's say you had this in sullivan they had you know the collective event they collapsed at the benches and then you have this thing in florida although it's not exclusively jewish there's enough jewish blood spilled to make them feel better it's all the same idea yeah all the same maybe so the first answer of everybody's question is that hashem has a plan and we don't know the plan okay yeah and so then comes the next question is we don't understand we just don't know anything that's going on so i'm just going to give you my perspective on it and you could agree disagree but i want to try to show it to you and again there's no one answer everybody will have their own thing perspective we go through life we make decisions we decide things for ourselves should we cross the street now should we cross the street later right is the car going to hit us is the car not going to hit us right before [Music] apartment building and it's still not

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00three things that happened that effectively yeah three things that happened in recent i say memory…
2. 6:49right so before you go into your rant and rave right after five minutes you found…
3. 13:21know and acknowledge which is a life force and included in that life forces hashem and…
4. 20:04something like that so if you have a belief in it if it's a challenge to…
5. 26:28it's because because we don't want to support the germans who destroyed us whereas the stratum…
6. 32:49masks and you had to follow like mice and everything else and all the things that…
7. 39:22how you read each one and then there's also those tagging which means something which we…
8. 45:54let's focus on ourselves are we going to be in a position that when he comes…
9. 52:34and it's up to us anything you want and he has the ability right it's just…
10. 58:58you could take me a court i don't have to give you a hundred bucks maybe…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.