Mishmar: Giving Presents on Shabbat

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

you a perfume for the house. Yeah. Another time they bring you a bottle of wine. Another time they're going to bring you what? But the problem that is a problem was a problem. >> The voucher is not a problem. I don't know. You tell me. So the question is >> soh why wouldn't the people say one minute one minute one minute one minute. So the question is >> yeah the question is is it permitted for me to give you something or not? I'm professor what do you say? >> Yes. Whatever you say >> I didn't say anything. I asked you the question. So you that's already a fail. >> He gave him the honor >> Yeah. >> professor. If you were in the class, he would fail him for some >> one more time. Huh? >> He quit a long time the class. He's still in the class. He's still there. >> Yeah. So one more time. Is it permitted or not? permitted or not permitted? >> One more time. One more time. >> Somebody comes to my house. Well, I want you to tell me. Is there a difference between Is there a difference between Shabbat? Is it the same thing or not? I want you to tell me I'm going right now to your house on Shabbat. I know that you needed a certain seph. I know that you needed a certain seph. Can I buy you the seph and bring it to you on Shabbat and give it to you as a present? >> No. >> Yeah. Can I bring you, for example, a nice matzah cover? Right. A nice matzah

Jump to a moment

1. 0:45you a perfume for the house. Yeah. Another time they bring you a bottle of wine.…
2. 6:42>> the and now be >> says you have to remember that when says something it…
3. 13:17it permitted Yeah. How in the world is it permitted for us to come and do…
4. 19:48it. Yeah. Some people they do that. They go to synagogue. >> Yeah. You have the…
5. 26:10that written? >> Yeah. Listen. Page four. You're allowed to measure for there is talking about…
6. 32:27How do you get the properties over? So they could actually do aan right they're right…
7. 38:51as is brought in what's written in right listen to this. He comes and he says…
8. 45:12of um the rabbi of the city of okay is the rabbi and the rabbi right…
9. 51:45Shabbat and even if it's going to be to make him happy and he's not even…
10. 58:17even though it's with glass is with right guys we're going through all of here we're…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.