Why Do Tzadikim Die Before Their Time? | Tzidkas Hatzadik #112 פרק פ״ד

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yaacov Haber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Sitka Sadic O pay which um is a rough um O here rough to learn and rough to um accept. Um but I I want to point out before we Um but I I want to point out before we begin that since O pay Olive Rep has been helping people understand why do the righteous suffer? Why do people die untimely deaths? Why do people end up running all around the world? um no and um pretty harsh about it. Uh if if uh you recall he said that nava nud is we recall he said that nava nud is we learned from kind and he kind was a nav and nud he was scattered he was running he was not allowed to be in one place even when he settled in one place he settle settled in Erit's note which was a sort of a refugee uh camp but he was never settled because uh he he killed he killed he um and we spent a lot of time explaining that he killed Havl must have been bash because Golos is only when you're ho Bash but the point is for our you're ho Bash but the point is for our purposes today that um sometimes a person finds themselves like having to be moved from one place to another place and uh so that that could be says rips because you killed somebody bash in fact he says vadai harag he definitely killed somebody bash but uh killing somebody um doesn't mean boom, you killed somebody. Killing somebody can mean that you were Melbourne Pave or Barab, which equate to killing someone. But there must be killing someone. But there must be something going on if you're nud Um, sometimes a person dies just to make room for another person. Um, in other words, you're taking up a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01Sitka Sadic O pay which um is a rough um O here rough to learn and…
2. 4:42always wondered um very strong statement but I always wondered where did he how like how…
3. 9:42he a long time after the whole story with the carbon pointed this out pages later…
4. 14:58>> it was and nobody else should read it >> uh that's a whole book the…
5. 19:34high >> so I'll show you ask the question. So from so how's that fit? Maybe…
6. 24:45He does not want any creation. You know like in the whole when when you talk…
7. 29:49from doesn't say that from talks about um educational like scholarship um we don't know that…
8. 34:34I got permission from Melik because this is the PK the operating PK of ours here.…
9. 39:41who was some BTO. So like you don't need to go to the Da Vinci Code…
10. 44:22I don't know. Um, used to be the rabbi of Vashul. No, you don't drive a…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.