The Beis Halevi, Rav Sheinberg, Shvus Ya'akov, and Rav Shach on the Lomdus of Lighting the Menorah

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

so one of the very first suggests in lincoln that discusses hanukkah is the suggya of kavsa zakakla or kafsa which means if the um you light the menorah and you put enough oil to last the shear for the half hour and it goes out immediately or let's say even if it doesn't go out but it's very shock it's very weak it's very light do you need to re-light the noira if it goes out what's up zuckerclaw or kafsa it's a machoke it's between raphuna and just blinked what and bleep the noise what did the camera okay we're good i think so so there's a macholic do we say kavsa zakakla if uh if the menorah goes out you must re-light it on the other hand riv krista holds kavsa and zakakla lemai so what do we hold anybody know do we hold we hold kafsa in we hope that if the narrator goes out you do not have to re-light it there's no obligation as long as you made the attempt to light it and uh it it burns so if it get it went out immediately it's fine you don't have you're not obligated to re-light it that's a gives a very interesting uh halacha illuminati says a courtyard that has two openings srikhashde neroys you need to light in two places so if you have a courtyard there's one opening on one side on uh peninsula boulevard one opening on oakland avenue let's say you know you have a corner house basically corner house and you have one you have one window or one door on one side of the street one

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32so one of the very first suggests in lincoln that discusses hanukkah is the suggya of…
2. 3:52here he probably didn't light there as well and therefore you need to light in both…
3. 7:33leaving why don't we say just like the guy is going to say just like he…
4. 11:30anyone who passes by will see it um knows that it was burning before me that…
5. 15:08not but they're going to be suspicious of you even you know like maybe somebody's gonna…
6. 18:51in other words when when are we suspicious of somebody let's say the show has three…
7. 22:43who not to down with a minion unless there's really only one door but if they're…
8. 26:21no no no right but then why is this guy walking by he should be home…
9. 29:59we're worried that if somebody sees that you didn't take up maybe you took off peya…
10. 33:43likes them okay so says don't say it doesn't make an afcomina because at the end…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.