Daf Yomi: Chullin 91 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

ahead of us today. Today's D is 91. We are picking up on 90b at the two dots which is 2468 10 lines up from the bottom. So said that the prohibition of ganosha applies both to the right thigh as well as to the left thigh. Says does not reflect the view of why not says ultimately holds that only applies to one of the legs, one of only applies to one of the legs, one of the thighs and logic dictates that's literally logic dictates that the thigh that it applies to is the right side. So says okay so when says that it applies to the right side no sense logic dictates is saying I'm definitively sure that it applies to the right side and what does he mean when he says logic dictates it's clear of you in this world view it it's clear of you in this world view it is clear that it is clear the right side that has the prohibition of only the right side and that's and he's he's absolutely clear on that all Another possibility is maybe he's unsure and when he says what does he mean logic dictates it means this is the way it seems logical to assume so it's interesting so in other words tells us that the prohibition of only applies to one side of the and he uses one side of the and he uses literally logic would dictate that it's the right soar is asking logic dictates And when he says that logic is Torah tells us so or no or again Torah is not clear it's not explicit but again logic would dictate just we could infer that it only applies to the right side. So the so let's analyze the says so this interesting is that the bones the senus and the noar

Jump to a moment

1. 1:32ahead of us today. Today's D is 91. We are picking up on 90b at the…
2. 5:41the prohibition of only applies to the right side on what's the case over here. The…
3. 9:51if you hold the was unequivocally clear that you have to go ahead it's only the…
4. 14:06okay leaves that open the leaves that open. Okay. Um fine let's go. If a person…
5. 18:20interesting that the of the is right, right? Because ultimately in the pause sorry was injured…
6. 22:24Sometimes Asov looks like a sadic. Sometimes Asov looks like a Russia like ankum. And that's…
7. 26:35holiest pursuits of the and engages in the struggle. The struggle was so intense that it…
8. 30:45traveling with all of his children, wives, grandchildren, presumably servants. Why is he alone? So, what…
9. 34:50that eat from that to whatever your car your house your money everything I have when…
10. 38:54Jacobu also rose for Jacob. What does this mean? So the says is so beautiful. So…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.