39 Melachos: Bishul (Part 4) | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

all right say good evening good evening Let's uh let's begin tonight we're going to focus a lot on the so remember again just to reorient ourselves a little bit so last week we spoke about the concept of of maintaining food on an open flame and the concept of concern that one may come to go ahead and Stoke or adjust the heat source and thereby again violate the potential issue of bishel and and hav so that's that's what we spoke that's that's what we spoke about as we spoke about last week we also spoke about the idea that the way to the way to avoid that ultimately again is througha anduma just just what I wanted to point out I didn't get to this last week but the one of the other ways in which we are able to go ahead and avoid the issues of is in number one so the says as follows he says so so far number one this is just the same exact L that we had that we had last week right this this same exact idea that you can't maintain food on an open flame with a manipul manipulable or changeable and alterable heat Source because of a concern that you may come to adjust the heat Source in order to accelerate the cooking process now again unless of course the food is fully cooked fine skip down a little bit oh last second last line oh B CL so this is an interesting idea so

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00all right say good evening good evening Let's uh let's begin tonight we're going to focus…
2. 3:37chabas let's say my child is not a third cooked at the onset of shabas so…
3. 7:39nothing to stoke they produce heat and then they simply incinerate so so those type of…
4. 11:45fully cooked solid so therefore again is there an issue of bishell is there an issue…
5. 15:50OD the pot should not have been set down during the entire time it was off…
6. 19:55even return the food to someone to another covered fire in other words the food need…
7. 23:31it can be looked at as a continuation of the original placement on the black because…
8. 27:37didn't think about these cases I always assumed that it's just one person but it's okay…
9. 31:44therefore when I take it off it's as if it never left and like it bungees…
10. 35:51that that if you didn't have to put it back so say so essentially they are…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.