Masechet Menahot Daf Yomi Daf 82

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Kadosh, welcome to our Masachet Menachot Daf Yomi Daf P Bet Amud Aleph 82A1. Okay? We were just talking about the following. We were speaking about the beer near that was in front of Rabbi Zira. He was sitting down and he was saying that we were talking that you cannot bring the breads from the Chitim Maaser Sheni, right? But Chitim that were purchased with Maot Maaser Sheni, you could bring it. So he went and he said, "What do you really say this even if it's Chitim Maot Maaser Sheni, you shouldn't bring it." He go. So he said, "What's the different reasonings?" So they said they learned it from the Shlamim. And the Shlamim they made they learned from Gzeira Shava Sham Sham Maaser Sheni. So he said, "Just like the Shlamim in Gufan Maaser, so to the Todah is in Gufan Maaser. These Chitim which were purchased with money of Maaser Sheni, Nami and Gufan Maaser." So this is where we're continuing today. Okay, it says "Eima Ta'ama Didi." Everybody has it? "Eima Ta'ama Didi." So this is four lines down, the last words of the line. "Eima Ta'ama Didi." Right? What am I'm going to say what is my reason that you cannot bring the breads from the Chitim which are purchased from Maot Maaser Sheni, right? What do we say? Todah. Right? The Todah Meheicha Kayefilah. How do you know that you cannot take, right? That you could buy the Todah from Maot Maaser Sheni. So he says he learns it from the Shlamim. U'shlamim itself, you learn it from Gzeira Shava Sham Sham Mi'maaser Sheni. Right? Mashlamim, just like the Shlamim and Mi'maaser, there's not a Maaser Sheni because basically the Shlamim is Basar and Maaser Sheni is from the Perot

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Kadosh, welcome to our Masachet Menachot Daf Yomi Daf P Bet Amud Aleph 82A1. Okay? We…
2. 2:37There's no kedushat shlamim. Okay? So, he says >> So, he cannot change from from No,…
3. 5:13trumah gedolah. Trumah gedolah goes to the Kohen Gadol or to the kohanim, sorry. Right? And…
4. 7:50argue that for sure you're going to be koneh. When is the machlokes according to Rebbi…
5. 10:59"tavash b'chova" it's a "chova" "v'ein ba ela min hachulin." It's only going to come from…
6. 13:36So, comes Rabbi Akiva and he says, "You know what? One second, why don't I I…
7. 16:10So now says the Gemara like this, right? So he comes and he says, right? Tomorrow…
8. 19:21was no Mishkan, there was no nothing. Pesach Midbar, there was still no Ma'aser Sheni, but…
9. 21:56have a kash, that's it. opinion and one is holding like the g'zeirah shavah and the…
10. 24:35Right? Like this. He says We read this in this week's again. Okay, so he says…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.