Masechet Makkot Daf Yomi Daf 19

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

1981. We're just going to start on 18b the last line where it says okay everyone has it from when are you going to be punished when you eat the so he says what does that mean when you go into the so once you go into the right and then you're going to come and you're going to eat it so you're going to be punished right why because uh that's it so kan what does that go like okay Tana did like this tana the And we learned to write that part of them were already placed inside the part of them were outside of the so he says the ones which are outside is still right and therefore he comes which means that they're going to be one. So holds that which means that if you have one utensil it doesn't combine them together. So if you put half the utensil inside the half the utensil outside the part which is outside is still considered outside. It's like and the one which is on the inside is like and for and therefore obviously only a is allowed to eat it and if the if somebody else eats it he's going to be and also if you were going to eat it outside of the you're going to be in trouble okay because once it's already inside that's it that's already remember only the quen eats the you bring the first fruits to the dash you read the you put it in front of the and what happens is now the cohen eats it theim goes to the ken okay Exactly.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:051981. We're just going to start on 18b the last line where it says okay everyone…
2. 3:30bring? No. Do you bring master shi? No. Do you bring right there? So he says…
3. 6:51bring it down at all because of the get okay so [Music] says one second when…
4. 10:04together. So the same thing each one on their own, they're not they're not comparable. So…
5. 13:18that just like you're not allowed to eat even if it doesn't need a mikdash. So…
6. 16:34He comes and he says like this the which is the end of the is talking…
7. 19:46became right even meaning like this we know right that there's such a thing as that…
8. 22:59and inside Jerusalem here we're talking about you cannot eat it because the word even though…
9. 26:06entrance. So if he's outside of line and the produce is on the inside, that's it.…
10. 29:21of Jerusalem now he comes and he eats it he's going to be one lashes why…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.