Daf Yomi: Chullin 29 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Yisrael. With that, let us begin today's daf is chof ches, November beautiful daf ahead of us today. We are picking up in on so today is 29th, chof ches, sorry. All right, we're picking up on chof ches 28b at the two dots. So the Mishnah says as follows, this is chatzi achad ba'of, which is 2 4 6 8 10 12 13 lines up from the bottom. So the Gemara says as follows. The Gemara says chatzi achad ba'of. It says Rav Amram, I'm sorry, actually we started this yesterday. Sorry, we're actually up to the first wide line. Tnan so tnan so let's remember again we ended up in yesterday's daf that when we say rov, what's the definition of rov? Does rov mean 50% or does rov mean 51%? So interestingly enough, this was a machlokes between Rav and Rav Kahana. So Rav said metza metza, 50/50 has a status of a rov. and Rav Kahana said metza metza 50 50 does not have a status of a rov. That was our fundamental machlokes. So, the Gemara now is going to kind of flush this out a little bit. And again, the Gemara's idea was that by shchita, do we essentially say that as long as the majority is not unslaughtered, then halacha l'maaseh that's a proper shchita, which is long as you cut 50% you're good to go. Or no, is the halacha you have to cut the majority, in which case you really would need to cut 51% in order for the shchita to be kosher. So, that's our machlokes. So, the Gemara says as follows, "Tnan." The Gemara says, "We learned, chatzi eiver b'of."

Jump to a moment

1. 1:01Yisrael. With that, let us begin today's daf is chof ches, November beautiful daf ahead of…
2. 4:48If you shecht it half of the gargeres, right? If you shecht it half of the…
3. 9:05not the rov." I So, what's the machlokes? But there is a machlokes Rav and Rav…
4. 13:20is about to walk is about to walk right so Rob has skins that 5050 ultimately…
5. 17:34blood when I do a regular about in but you need the blood right remember I…
6. 21:55by. As seen by Rashi Amora, so as seen by Rashi says rasha of the colon…
7. 26:11street ultimately you can the street is good now what do you see from here I…
8. 30:31Incredible. So again, that the here the Gemara is saying is since by Yom Kippur, since…
9. 34:44happens? Someone else comes along and says, "Let's let's finish this. Let's finish this." And that…
10. 38:57mikdash, therefore you're totally good to go. Fascinating, wasn't it? So what is the fundamental definition…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.