Daf Yomi: Bava Kamma 73 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we hope the Merit of and the families we also dedicate of course Master Sergeant hope the mer of and his family with that let us begin today's is 73 and we are picking up on 73a at the two dots add the two dots which are two four six eight lines down from the top just to orient ourselves a little bit so if you remember again we are in the midst embroiled embroiled in this dramatic and about when are found to be this feels much more like a like a than anything else but so says so when become so how does that impact them so ultimately again says it impacts them so that even going back retroactively a AOS that they gave is disqualified in other words once you are designated as an that that's wrong ah thank you thank you that impacts that impacts ultimately again your status even retroactively says no ultimately again it only means from this Point going forward so that's our ongoing over here which we have not yet resolved so let's go say I just I'll just point out just before we get into the just understand that this is an incredibly dramatic as well what's this happens all the time you find good people who do very bad things right or good people who do kind of bad things or do good people who just do bad things right but in other words even the most righteous of people commit and the sh that often kinds of comes up in our mind is when you see a good people do a good person do something bad how does that reflect on their good activity in the past right

Jump to a moment

1. 1:03we hope the Merit of and the families we also dedicate of course Master Sergeant hope…
2. 4:48your what's your financial penalty sheep four right four it's not four right four or five…
3. 9:01Whatsapp voice notes on two times speed I expect you to do at least the same…
4. 13:19reciprocal punishment for Testimony regarding the slaughter R Mar say you're right what's the case it's…
5. 17:43all look atash says remember again we're trying to there is this interesting interesting Dynamic over…
6. 22:12testimony say but at the end of the day if it was one group of witnesses…
7. 25:53utterances that you recite within immediate proximity of each other become one cohesive verbal unit so…
8. 30:16statements attached or not and when we say attached by the way attached means a number…
9. 35:08interesting this idea of you let it graze and then you use half of the money…
10. 41:18incredible it's pretty incredible so first of all again we weren't even expecting this right this…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.