Zevachim 111 (cycle 13) | Daf Yomi with Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay. All right. Say let's begin. Today's daff is alf1. We are picking up on the bottom of on the bottom of kufu 110b. We actually left off we actually left off right at the last three words on the so just to reorient ourselves a little bit. So the quoted an interesting the quoted just a few lines above if one goes ahead and does three of water outside of the one will be. Remember again yesterday we discussed about how much water you actually have to go ahead and pour in order for you to be we discussed all that yesterday. It says that if somebody goes in and does on three of water outside of the base of mdash on said if you filled it up if you filled up the cle for the purpose of then wanted to know what exactly is between those two opinions. So says that ultimately again over here is whether or not we're offered up were offered up in the midbar. Now Rashi explains somewhat of a lengthy Rashi but Rashi explains that what that actually Rashi explains that what that actually means is what they're really arguing about is whether or not require aaris does a require does require a service utensil under normal circumstances when doing something inside of the Bikdash. So one requires let's say again for example one has to receive the blood sacrificial blood in a cliche it's in a service utensil. So the Shiloh here is ultimately again does require a or not. So points out that the Tanakama holds that water for does not

Jump to a moment

1. 0:08Okay. All right. Say let's begin. Today's daff is alf1. We are picking up on the…
2. 4:27So we'll say here's the shila. The sh is if you fill up a if you…
3. 8:31up on that take a look at for just a moment four lines down in the…
4. 12:47really riveting makus because this makus will say is a twofold maklo number one it's a…
5. 17:36matter what you do afterwards. is of the opinion they know that that the pouring out…
6. 21:45from outside of the ultimately again everyone agrees that it's not then the way you could…
7. 26:03thing as so therefore again it's invalid it's an therefore even if you subsequently go ahead…
8. 30:46inside and then offers it up outside the he will be putter. Why on the other…
9. 35:20says in fact the point of contention the is in the case ultimately again of so…
10. 39:32that's the case of if you offer up you'll be for if you inside the say…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.