Daf Yomi: Bava Metzia 44 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

incredible also to be a new per today so let's get started today's is 44 and we are picking up on at about 20 lines up actually if you see TOA the over there and just move your finger to the left and about two lines up you'll be exactly where you are RAB AA om say remember again going back to yesterday's mishna we had the fascinating discussion really riveting discussion about if I deposit something discussion about if I deposit something with a Sher and then the object he let's say again he ends up misappropriating it or it ends up breaking or getting lost and the value of the item changes over time at what value is the Sher obligated to go ahead and compensate me the owner of the object so we had a threeway in the M we had ultimately again says you pay sh always pays the higher of the two amounts whichever the I always pay the sh always pays the higher amount the higher value B higher amount the higher value B says which literally meant at the time that the item was removed we spent a considerable amount of time yesterday trying to figure out what exactly that means and now we up who says so you pay in accordance with the value of the item at the time that the Sher is brought to B literally means a claim so at the time that the claim is lodged okay Rashi says over here fine now we're going to be

Jump to a moment

1. 1:01incredible also to be a new per today so let's get started today's is 44 and…
2. 6:23will establish your guilt or your innocence we know this but even if you have witnesses…
3. 11:37so again so just to see what's happening over here is you see a very strong…
4. 16:47forward be optimistic be hopeful put your trust in our back that's and if you hold…
5. 22:31this mishna maybe the reason why ruen is saying this in front of two witnesses is…
6. 27:45barel subsequently breaks what is Ru for right so says that's only if it breaks so…
7. 32:50again to misappropriate doesn't do anything we don't we don't hold like so intention does but…
8. 38:32so once Ru gives me the gold coins and I do I take possession of the…
9. 43:51Braes wow wow said if after you pay for something you absolutely have the H right…
10. 49:02merchandise and silver is the coin now watch this so if you hold that silver compared…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.