Daf Yomi: Bava Kama 47 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

lines remember again yesterday we had the really fascinating case of remember two cases in mishna case number one case number one was a sh that went ahead and gour a par pregnant par we find the dead right the dead par and the calf we don't know again was the was the cow pregnant at the time of the Goring or not so remember again this opened up the door so Mish said the owner of the sh has to pay for the power and quarter quarter for the calf we then then went on to really open our eyes that this is the position of suus what a when you have doubt about a monetary claim ultimately again you split it you split it so therefore we're unsure about the status of the calf and therefore so we split it should be possibly therefore he pay quarter damages the then remember Mish brought up the reverse case what was the reverse case a cow that was pregnant goes ahead and Gores and kills a Shar right so say then after the damage is done we find the calf and the calf has given birth what don't sorry we found the cow and the cow is given birth what don't we know what don't we know was the cow at the time of the damage so you'll say to yourself who cares well it matters why does it matter because the sh is if the cow was pregnant at the time of the damage then what then in essence there were two damagers there was the cow and the calf if the cow ever had given birth before the damage and there was only one damager I.E the cow I.E the cow so once

Jump to a moment

1. 1:12lines remember again yesterday we had the really fascinating case of remember two cases in mishna…
2. 6:45someone if it's not in existence so Rashi again we're not going to get into the…
3. 11:42determine the amount of Damages that he could collect from each of them that's model said…
4. 16:33don't know was the cow pregnant with the calf at the time of the damage or…
5. 21:33interestingly enough so again just two different methods of valuation you might have thought that maybe…
6. 26:18worth what saying is like this is how do we attribute certain certain value of the…
7. 31:11assumption of responsibility hold on to this next case Ru brings his fruit into the property…
8. 35:56going toe you enter without permission whatever happens is on you it's on you you're damaged…
9. 40:56ultimately again over the property of sh which is a which is a pretty which is…
10. 45:48two entities in this world that could utter anything and that's and man speech is what…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.