Daf Yomi: Bava Metzia 22 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Maya hman in memory of her father Ru benuel and in the Merit of the health and joy for her entire family Yan SAR kelman in honor of the birth of their son and memory of Staff Sergeant David we hope that in the all of the families and together with both with that let us begin we have a lot to do today and uh as always never never enough time so today's but we are have a lot to do so today's D is 22 we are starting on 21b and we are starting 18 lines down from the bottom so say again if you remember if you remember so we were dealing with the fting regarding shalom namely Ruben loses an object but he is not aware yet that he has lost the object it is the kind of object that upon becoming aware of the loss he will definitely experience Yos he'll definitely experience Yos so the Shila now becomes I find the object before ruin even knows that he lost it am I allowed to keep the object now before Yos has occurred knowing that yayos will ultimately occur not and therefore I do not have the ability to keep the object says it is is bringing up a series of cases trying to bolster one opinion VI another opinion said that if you find scattered money right I'm walking down and I find scattered money I am permitted to go ahead and keep that money says understand why is that permitted I the owner doesn't know that he lost it so this Cas

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32Maya hman in memory of her father Ru benuel and in the Merit of the health…
2. 5:02you're allowed to keep it you're allowed to keep it why because a Bas medish is…
3. 9:19follows listen to this let's say you find dried figs are dried figs you find dried…
4. 13:34is washing it away from him so he sees it he sees it he knows he's…
5. 17:52here so we'll say it's a case where I could save my property but it's not…
6. 22:36you should have done even nicer produce and he has nicer produce so that shows that…
7. 26:58good because it's clear that he only wanted to use B incredible tells a story along…
8. 31:16do it okay let's go right there says say we know we've actually seen this before…
9. 35:37to happen what does have to happen I have to be acutely aware and desirous of…
10. 40:06no the object is effectively he wherever someone finds it they're permitted to keep it the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.