Daf Yomi: Bava Basra 97 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

picking up on 96b the last line so the says as follows remember again in yesterday's we had this very interesting case about what is the status again the ostensibly the topic of our sugya isas and specifically again what is the bra over a drink that is made by pouring water over the wine over the grape pulps right or the you know the the the grape drgs after you go ahead and you press the grapes they go ahead and make mine so you have the leftover pulp if you mix in water with that pulp what is the status of the resulting liquid does it have the status of wine and therefore it gets a bre P offin or perhaps it has the status of colored water or something else and therefore only gets a shahak so we had that yesterday and the actually spoke about this interesting idea but maybe it depends what you get out after you pour in in other words if you're pouring in three cups of water and get out three cups of liquid maybe that's still water right you go ahead and you pour out three cups or three cups and you get out four cups then uh that could be wine you pour in three cups get out three and a half cups that could be so really do people argue in other words in a case where you're putting in X and get out x + y is there really an argument about the status of the resulting liquid we

Jump to a moment

1. 0:47picking up on 96b the last line so the says as follows remember again in yesterday's…
2. 4:33over it is the resulting liquid Myer or not so again everyone agrees if you so…
3. 8:15incredible an interesting case over here what if you have the drags the pulp and the…
4. 12:05and number two which the the top of the D is is it in or not…
5. 15:47you say you soak it in water you pour water over it any resulting liquid that…
6. 20:04contact with a liquid right and any liquid but one of the seven liquids take a…
7. 23:59them for the purpose of good because all if if all I do is shut down…
8. 27:37purposes for for okay what is coming to exclude maybe it's coming to exclude grape juice…
9. 32:01excluding black wine so black wine also sounds like maybe wine that turned a little bit…
10. 35:41sing's whether or not s souring wine can be used if is coming to exclude diluted…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.