Daf Yomi: Chullin 98 | Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

98 we are picking up at the two dots on 97b four lines up on the bottom of non kosher egg gets mixed in with a whole bunch of other eggs. So the egg the non kosher egg is ble but the egg itself is not part of the tally of shishim. Some more about that in just a moment. So now obviously this is telling us that when a non-coosher egg falls into falls into a mixture with kosher eggs that the non-coosher egg emits flavor. Is that true? true? There's a famous expression. I guess it's famous if you know it. But it's a famous expression like water like egg like water of an egg which in other words when somebody wants to go ahead and convey that something does not give off flavor they say ah it's like water from an egg which see which seem to indicate that an egg does not emit flavor. So what's going on over here what's the case herea ultimately we're talking about an egg that has a chick inside of it. So again that has a chick inside of it. So again as Rashi points out remember we saw the say that essentially the chick inside of the egg is considered to be in the and therefore the Mishna speaks about an egg getting mixed in a prohibited egg getting mixed in with with kosher eggs. We're not talking about an egg from a non-coo. We're talking about an egg with a chicken. In that case it becomes ana emits flavor. But inami if a if a non-coosher egg were to get mixed in with kosher eggs that non-cooser egg would not go ahead and inhibit the other

Jump to a moment

1. 1:0298 we are picking up at the two dots on 97b four lines up on the…
2. 4:40if the eggs have the ability to infuse flavor into the tar eggs and everything is…
3. 8:18account what the pot absorbed from the to which again I say. So, this actually goes…
4. 11:59cutting in half the whereas normally you need 60 times the amount of riveted material in…
5. 15:35What about a egg from? We're going to get to [clears throat] all of that. But…
6. 20:00first opinion said it's 60. Second opinion said it's 100. Interesting enough the says interestingly enough…
7. 23:43so going to first we separate the fourlegg, the coins portion, but then we cook everything…
8. 27:20But according to the second approach in the second approach, second approach, everyone agrees that you…
9. 30:58create a paradigm maybe not maybe it's the exception maybe this is the one case where…
10. 34:43they're both mixed together and ultimately again they're still not they're still not so from here…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.