Menachos 27 | Daf Yomi with Rabbi Shmuel Silber

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

For in order for a comet to be kasher, it must be fully intact. We'll say similar again is the minimum measure for a carbon. If you are missing if you are missing an if you are missing any part of an is even if the majority of the isaron is intact. Nevertheless, the is compromisedly by wine. will say this about wine liations. In order for a wine libation ultimately again to be valid, the entire amount must be intact. Similarly again by oil, right? Which is talking about again also by carbonos. The full measure of the oil must be intact. The fine flour as well as the oil are one another. In other words, you have to have both the flour and the oil in order for the carbon for the to be valid. Similarly again by the carbon thet right and the leava the is the frankincense must both be present in order for the carbon to be says. What's the reason for this? So we're going to see now all of the items mentioned in the Mishna the understands that in order for them to be kasher you must have the full amount. So what we're going to see is the is going to learn out each of these items. How do how do you know the need of full by the kamit? How do I know that the entire kam must be intact and that if any part of it is missing ultimately again the carbon is compromised the says you must have the comet in its entirety. Ultimately again twice the complete I think that there are chairs missing. I think they took chairs from here for the uh y setup. All right. So we'll have to we'll have we'll have to

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00For in order for a comet to be kasher, it must be fully intact. We'll say…
2. 3:12So say we're talking about the accompanies. So the says use the word mish to teach…
3. 6:56we'll say the two different parts. We'll discuss this in greater depth in the gimar but…
4. 10:45of the this is how it has to be done. The three different ingredients in the…
5. 14:02to be on the table in front of you at the same time do you need…
6. 17:50fruits require the ones that don't produce fruit and say the same thing is with so…
7. 21:42together? Do they need to be bound together? The answer is no. But because of the…
8. 24:57very specific type of direction. So if it wasn't done with the right intent or wasn't…
9. 28:47ultimately again you go ahead and your point of good morning. So follow so what are…
10. 32:39if there's going to be of ultimately again for what outside of the kesh I'm just…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.