Sefer Yona: Chapter 1 - The Malbim Explains Yona's Plan to Run from Hashem

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

should tell them and therefore in fact if he doesn't listen to Hashem he's not being cultivation of Wasa he's not holding in his navua because Hashem didn't tell him anything to say he just says who crawl out call out to it so Yaya figures in the meantime before Hashem gives me further instruction let me get out of here let me go to khudzarets somebody sent me an email I'll just say it's hard to respond to all the emails let's say over the Kasha he asked um so what if Yana goes Torres the halacha is that once the navi begins to halacha is that once the navi begins to receive nabua in Arce Israel he could continue receiving prophecy in hussara so it's really not going to help if he goes Torres um and as we're going to see the map and we'll deal with that um because he specifically took a certain route he took the yam and on the yam a person's mind cannot be settled person is swaying back and forth okay I want to begin today's share by revisiting a question that Rod Donald asked last week actually you got a good asked last week actually you got a good a compliment on your question um and the The Listener who's a big time of hakum said that he agreed with my answer although after thinking about it um I'm not sure how confident I am that it's a correct answer um the Melbourne asked the following question we don't find anywhere that Hashem sends a prophet to make goyum duchova Hashem doesn't have that relationship with the umai Salam that the protest is such that he communicates with them only to only to Kal Israel so

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30should tell them and therefore in fact if he doesn't listen to Hashem he's not being…
2. 3:34they punishing Claudia song and the album says because Regina saw that this would bring about…
3. 7:13we would be worthy but we weren't worthy because we didn't we didn't do chuva so…
4. 10:48maybe this type of mission is not together in a vua maybe this type of mission…
5. 14:39and from there he will not send him to say prophecyam he chose to go down…
6. 18:22empty ones right he paid for the people on there and he paid for the uh…
7. 21:27its mind the book thought about breaking yeah says the Melbourne vashem the air has the…
8. 25:06question is boats don't break in the middle of the sea they drown the answer is…
9. 28:47why is Jana going to sleep isn't that unusual here they're in sakanas their lives are…
10. 32:26his opinion is doesn't have a dinner because the water comes into the room uh Joanna…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.